Dr. Owens
The creature in the containnt cell fascinated more than anything I'd studied in thirty years of governnt work.
D'Artagnan—"Dart" according to young Henderson—demonstrated problem-solving abilities that suggested sapience, not just animal instinct. Over five days of observation, patterns erged.
I activated the puzzle box chanism. Food pellet inside, three-step lock to open.
Dart approached. Clicked thoughtfully. Manipulated the first latch with its forelimb, then the second, then the third. Retrieved the pellet in under thirty seconds.
"Remarkable," I murmured into the recorder. "Subject demonstrates sequential problem-solving. Retention from previous trials. Learning curve comparable to corvids or primates."
Dustin pressed against the observation glass. "Told you he was smart."
"Intelligence and autonomy aren't the sa thing," Steve said from behind us. His corruption had spread to his neck now, black veins visible even under his collar. "Ants solve problems too. Doesn't make them individuals."
"Ants don't rember specific people."
"Let's test that hypothesis." I entered the observation room—not the cell itself, but the adjacent chamber separated by reinforced glass. "Dustin, co here."
The boy joined . I opened the intercom.
"D'Artagnan," I called.
The creature's head swiveled toward the speaker. Face-petals twitched.
"Now watch," I told Dustin. "Steve, join us. Lucas, you too."
Three people stood in the observation room now. Dart could see all of us through the glass.
Its reaction was imdiate and specific.
Dustin
Dart's clicking changed pitch the mont he saw . Not the aggressive clicking he made at Dr. Owens' assistants. Not the curious clicking when Lucas approached.
Different. Higher. Almost... happy?
He pressed against the glass where I stood, face-petals opening and closing in rapid succession. Body language shifted—less tense, more relaxed.
"He knows you," Dr. Owens said. "Specifically you. Not just 'human.' You individually."
"I fed him for two days before bringing him in." My throat felt tight. "He rembers."
Steve crossed his arms. "Or the Mind Flayer programd him to recognize Dustin. To make us trust him. Long-term infiltration strategy."
"That's paranoid even for you, Steve."
"It's tactical. The Mind Flayer is ancient and patient. You think it can't play long gas?"
Dr. Owens watched Dart track Dustin's movent along the glass. "If this is deception, it's remarkably sophisticated. The creature shows genuine preference, not just recognition. Stress responses lower when you're present, Henderson. Heart rate decreases. That suggests emotional bonding, not strategic mimicry."
"See?" I looked at Steve. "Dart chose . He's not just a drone."
"Maybe." Steve's corruption pulsed visibly. "Or maybe that's exactly what the Mind Flayer wants us to think."
Steve
The philosophical debate raged for an hour.
Mike argued demo-dogs were hive drones—extensions of Mind Flayer will, no autonomy. Lucas agreed. Max remained uncertain. Will stayed quiet, face troubled.
Dustin stood firm. "Dart is different. I know he is."
"Based on what?" I challenged. "Feelings? Hope? Dustin, this thing ate your cat."
"I know!" His voice cracked. "I know what he did. But animals kill. That's instinct. He didn't know ws was... was family."
"And now he does?"
"I think so. Yeah."
I wanted to believe him. Wanted to accept that sothing connected to the Mind Flayer could break free, could choose differently. But I'd seen too much, absorbed too much corruption, felt the hive mind's vast coordination.
Individual thought seed impossible in that network.
Dr. Owens cleared his throat. "Gentlen, I have a proposal. We test Dart's cooperation. If he's autonomous, he might help us. If he's a drone, he won't."
"Help us how?" Hopper asked.
"Intelligence gathering. If Dart recognizes tunnel cara footage, he might identify pack locations, nest sites, weak points in the network."
Worth trying. If Dart revealed nothing, we lost nothing. If he helped...
"Do it," I said.
Dustin
They brought Dart into a separate room—reinforced, monitored, but larger than his cell. Dr. Owens set up a screen showing tunnel cara feeds.
I sat inside with Dart, which Steve hated but allowed. "If he attacks you, I'm coming in."
"He won't."
Dart settled beside , clicking softly. I scratched behind his head-frills—spot he liked. He leaned into the touch.
Dr. Owens played the first video. Tunnel junction, empty passage, organic walls pulsing.
Dart watched, bored.
Second video. Another empty tunnel.
No reaction.
Third video. Demo-dog pack moving through a chamber.
Dart's clicking spiked. Sharp, rapid, agitated. He stood, approached the screen, face-petals opening. His forelimb touched the glass, pointing at specific sections.
"He's reacting," Dr. Owens noted. "Play the next one."
Fourth video showed breeding chamber we'd discovered yesterday.
Dart went ballistic. Clicking beca shrieking. He spun toward the map on the wall, launched himself at it, pointed with his snout at specific location.
"That's... that's the downtown convergence point," Bob said, checking coordinates. "The hub."
Dart circled the map, pointed at three other locations. Clicked at different frequencies for each.
"He's identifying sites," I breathed. "Pack locations. He's showing us where they are."
Steve
Dart's intelligence proved accurate.
We scouted the three locations he'd indicated. Found exactly what he'd shown us—two major pack concentrations and a secondary breeding chamber we'd missed.
The creature had given us critical tactical intelligence.
"Still think he's just a drone?" Dustin asked smugly.
"I think it's suspicious the Mind Flayer would let him help us." But my conviction wavered. The data was too good, too specific. Either Dart was legitimately helping, or this was the most elaborate trap in history.
Dr. Owens docunted everything. "This suggests demo-dogs possess individual cognition within the hive structure. Perhaps so can develop autonomy given the right circumstances."
"Like Dustin raising him," Mike said slowly. "Imprinting."
"Exactly. Early exposure to human bonding might override hive directives." Owens watched Dart through the glass. "Or strengthen them enough to allow choice."
"Or," I countered, "the Mind Flayer is using him to feed us accurate information now so we trust false information later."
"You're exhausting," Dustin said.
"I'm careful. There's a difference."
Will approached, hand extended toward Dart's chamber. "Can I... can I try sothing?"
"Try what?" Joyce asked, imdiately protective.
"I can feel the hive. If Dart's truly disconnected, I'll know."
Will
Dart watched approach. Clicked curiously.
I pressed my hand against the glass, closed my eyes, reached out with the part of still connected to the hive mind.
The Mind Flayer's presence flooded in imdiately—vast, cold, patient. I felt the tunnel network, the demo-dog packs, the infected citizens Steve didn't know about yet.
And I felt Dart.
He was... separate. Connected to the hive mind like tributary to river, but flowing differently. The Mind Flayer's will touched him, but didn't control him. Not completely.
"He's different," I whispered. "Still connected, but... choosing not to listen."
"You're sure?" Steve asked.
"Yeah. He's like . Part of the hive, but fighting it. Trying to be himself instead of just... part of it."
Dustin's relief was palpable. "See? I told you!"
Steve's expression remained troubled. But he nodded slowly. "Okay. We keep Dart. Use his intelligence. But he stays contained. The second he shows hive behavior, he gets neutralized."
"Fair," Dustin agreed.
Dustin
I stayed late watching Dart sleep. The creature curled in the corner of his cell, clicking softly in dreams.
"You're different from them, aren't you?" I whispered through the intercom. "You chose . Chose to help. That's real."
Dart's clicking shifted, almost like answering.
Steve appeared in the doorway, silent as death. His corruption looked worse in the dim light—black veins spreading like infection across his skin.
"You really believe he's autonomous?" Steve asked quietly.
"Yeah. I do."
"Hope you're right." Steve's hand touched the observation glass. "Because if the Mind Flayer has long-term plans for any creature that appears to defect, we're walking into a trap."
"Or we're making an ally. You can't save everyone by assuming the worst."
"Can't save anyone by assuming the best either."
We stood in silence, watching Dart sleep. Two perspectives—one hopeful, one paranoid. Both trying to survive the impossible.
Steve left eventually, corruption trailing behind him like shadow.
I stayed until dawn.
Note:
Please give good reviews and power stones itrings more people and more people ans more chapters?
My Patreon is all about exploring 'What If' tilines, and you can get instant access to chapters far ahead of the public release.
Choose your journey:
Tiline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access 5 new chapters weekly.
Tiline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Tiline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the mont I finish writing them. No more waiting.
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon/Whatif0
User Comments
0 comments from readers