They were all classmates of Ma Ming and knew him fairly well. In their eyes, Ma Ming, though he had started studying under Qin Mu earlier and knew more about the law than they did, wasn’t so overwhelmingly impressive. The statent Ma Ming just made, however, was forceful and hit directly at the heart of the matter. The expression on Tian Shulan’s lawyer’s face said it all; after Ma Ming spoke, this seemingly impressive lawyer’s deanor actually turned grave.
From the plaintiff’s bench, Ma Ming bypassed the prosecutor and Shi Liangping and continued, "Furthermore, in the law, there are three elents to the constitution of a cri of incitent.
"First, there must be the intent to incite, along with the foreseeability of the criminal outcos of the incitent. Tian Shulan’s actions are clearly intentional under the circumstances of needing money, aiming to deceive others for financial gain and ultimately to misappropriate their property.
"Second, objectively speaking, there must be an act of incitent. According to the evidence presented by the prosecutor just now, it sufficiently proves that Tian Shulan had engaged in behavior such as instigating, inciting, and guiding ng Lei.
"Third, the incited individual must have a certain ability to bear responsibility. And ng Lei, now an adult, does not fall into categories such as persons with disabilities, dentia, or intellectual disabilities. Therefore, Tian Shulan must bear criminal responsibility for the incitent!"
Legal provisions and theories poured from Ma Ming’s mouth, one after another, passionate, ardent, resounding, and forceful. Upon seeing this, Tian Shulan’s lawyer frowned tightly, clearly contemplating a counter-strategy.
This scene also shocked Shi Liangping, who was beside Ma Ming. He looked blankly at his client, his expression quite complex. He wasn’t a novice attorney and had fought many lawsuits, but he had never seen any client refute the opposing lawyer in court as Ma Ming just had. This was simply beyond belief, utterly astounding.
「Jin City.」
In the nursing ho, a few middle-aged people who had stopped by beca engrossed in the broadcast. They stood still, not leaving, as the nursing ho staff patiently explained the situation from the previous hearings, "educating" them.
"This couple... one is more ruthless than the other," one of the middle-aged n remarked with a sigh, gazing at the two in the defendant’s dock. The spouses were at odds in court, each trying to get the other a heavier sentence. As a result, this hearing began with the prosecutor suggesting a fourteen-year sentence for one and a twelve-year sentence for the other.
"I think... it’s all because Qin Mu ddled in it," sighed the middle-aged man from the car sales industry, his gaze carrying a hint of wariness. He looked sowhat uneasy. Turning his head, he tried to find Qin Mu among the crowd in the yard watching the live broadcast. It was as if there were a ticking ti bomb among them.
But there were simply too many people in the yard. Everyone was watching the live broadcast intensely, occasionally gathering to discuss the developnts. Now and then, bursts of cheers erupted.
"Bravo! Ma Ming is quite skilled; that was a great example! Incitent is incitent—if the act exists, she’s an accomplice!"
"Tian Shulan still hasn’t given up, constantly trying to absolve herself of guilt."
"You follow your spouse for better or for worse. Xiao ng is such a good young man; she wouldn’t want to see him bullied in prison, right?"
"If nothing goes awry, the case should be decided today, shouldn’t it?"
Zhang Qingyuan and the others were emotionally stirred. Seeing Ma Ming’s performance, they couldn’t help but applaud.
anwhile, in the crowd, Qin Mu watched Ma Ming’s performance with a pleased expression. Over the past few days, having nothing particular to do, he had communicated remotely with Ma Ming, sharing all his defense strategies, insights, and thods. But theory was one thing; Ma Ming’s ability to perform so well in court ant he had truly put in the effort.
Within the live broadcast of the trial, after brief contemplation, Tian Shulan’s lawyer once again put forth a sharp rebuttal: "The evidence presented by the prosecutor just now can rely prove that my client committed an act of incitent.
"But in reality, according to criminal law regulations on the cri of incitent, it specifically refers to instilling one’s criminal intent into a person who initially had no such intent. This is done through thods such as persuasion, enticent, prompting, urging, bribery, or threats, causing them to commit the cri according to the inciter’s intent.
"In this case, ng Lei was already involved in illegal lending during his university years, long before he ever t my client; his criminal intent was persistent. Regardless of whether my client incited him or not, his intent to commit a cri did not originate from my client.
"Therefore, the evidence presented by the prosecutor is insufficient to prove that my client is an inciter."
In front of everyone in the courtroom, Tian Shulan’s lawyer, with this brilliant performance, shook the trial once more.
Back in the nursing ho, Zhang Qingyuan and the others were taken aback by this sudden turn of events.
"What did that lawyer just say? According to criminal law, Tian Shulan isn’t an inciter?"
"This lawyer is quite adept; it’s obvious Tian Shulan spared no expense."
"And ng Lei’s lawyer isn’t saying a word at this juncture."
"I have a feeling the case is about to be turned upside down..."
The crowd furrowed their brows, involuntarily starting to worry. They had seen for themselves what Tian Shulan had done. Their simple sense of justice told them that such a person should also go to prison alongside ng Lei. But Tian Shulan’s lawyer was clearly exploiting legal loopholes, trying to argue away the cri of incitent.
User Comments
0 comments from readers